Check whether a comparison can be chained
Test the property of the chosen rule first.
Transitivity means that “A outranks B” and “B outranks C” always imply “A outranks C”. Check whether your particular comparison has this property before chaining it. Not every rule for beating another item does.
What to do
- Name the relation: numerical “greater than” or winning under specified game rules.
- Write the initial pairs and check the third directly against the relation's definition.
- Keep the conclusion limited to that rule; a cycle of wins is not itself a game error.
Example
Fictional game with only these wins: A beats B, B beats C, C beats A. So A does not beat C despite the mistaken chain. Numbers differ: 3>2 and 2>1 give 3>1. Do not substitute numerical order for the game rule.
My Day · Windows
My Day can hold the pairs and explanation. You check whether chaining is valid.