My Day✳All blog articles ↗

For or since: duration or starting point

In an ongoing state, for six weeks gives a duration and since Monday gives a starting point.

In these ongoing present-perfect examples, identify the meaning of the time expression first. Six weeks states a duration: for six weeks. Monday names a starting point: since Monday. These are two different fictional people; without an observation date, since Monday does not give an exact duration. This exercise does not cover every meaning of for/since or imply that for is used only with the present perfect.

Separate cases: a six weeks period and the Monday starting point. No shared scale; the second duration is unknown.
Separate cases: a six weeks period and the Monday starting point. No shared scale; the second duration is unknown.

What to do

  1. Decide whether the expression names a period or its beginning: six weeks and Monday have different roles.
  2. In the supplied ongoing contexts, choose for for the duration and since for the starting point, keeping the complete English sentences.
  3. Label the meaning of each phrase and test yourself without the labels. Do not equate Monday with six weeks or invent a calendar duration.

Example

Two separate fictional contexts: Lea has kept this notebook for six weeks. — duration: six weeks. Mina has kept this notebook since Monday. — starting point: Monday; duration unknown without an observation date.

My Day · Windows

In My Day, manually save the two English lines, meaning labels and a revision task. Check the rule in its source; My Day is not a grammar checker.

Buy My Day for Windows ↗