My Day✳All blog articles ↗

Does the new list replace or extend the old one?

Establish replacement or addition before updating list membership.

A new short list does not explain what happens to earlier items. Full replacement and addition produce different results. If the operation is unstated, ask first and retain both original messages for comparison.

Replacement: 2 items; addition would give 3
Replacement: 2 items; addition would give 3

What to do

  1. Record the previous membership using stable labels for every item.
  2. Find explicit confirmation of replacement or addition; list length is not confirmation.
  3. Build the result under that rule and check what happened to every previous item.

Example

Fictionally, the old list is A,B. Confirmed: “The new complete list A,C replaces the previous one.” The result is A,C, 2 items; B was deliberately excluded. By contrast, “add C” would produce A,B,C, 3 items. Only replacement applies here; the second branch illustrates the difference.

My Day · Windows

Save this note manually in My Day.

Buy My Day for Windows ↗