My Day✳All blog articles ↗

Detect a circular explanation

Restating a claim does not provide independent support.

Check whether a conclusion relies only on a claim justified by that same conclusion. Seek independent support. A circle in this justification should not be confused with a system of connected definitions.

Checked entries: “Bridge—8” and “Park—12”
Checked entries: “Bridge—8” and “Park—12”

What to do

  1. Write the conclusion and its offered reason separately, then identify what supports that reason.
  2. Find an observation that can be checked without first accepting the conclusion.
  3. Check selected cases and state the limit, without automatically extending it to the whole set.

Example

Fictional claim: “The index is accurate because its page numbers are right; they are right because the index is accurate.” Independently checked “Bridge—8” and “Park—12” lead to the named sections. Those checks support the entries, not the whole index.

My Day · Windows

My Day can hold the argument sketch and check results. You assess the reasoning yourself.

Buy My Day for Windows ↗