Detect a circular explanation
Restating a claim does not provide independent support.
Check whether a conclusion relies only on a claim justified by that same conclusion. Seek independent support. A circle in this justification should not be confused with a system of connected definitions.
What to do
- Write the conclusion and its offered reason separately, then identify what supports that reason.
- Find an observation that can be checked without first accepting the conclusion.
- Check selected cases and state the limit, without automatically extending it to the whole set.
Example
Fictional claim: “The index is accurate because its page numbers are right; they are right because the index is accurate.” Independently checked “Bridge—8” and “Park—12” lead to the named sections. Those checks support the entries, not the whole index.
My Day · Windows
My Day can hold the argument sketch and check results. You assess the reasoning yourself.