Separate a score tie from list order
The first row does not win when the scores are equal.
If two options have the same total, the scoring model has not distinguished them. Alphabetical order or row position adds no advantage. Preserve the tie and decide separately how to proceed. Do not alter weights afterwards to manufacture a preferred winner.
What to do
- Define criteria, weights and scale direction before scoring; higher values should represent a better contribution.
- Check both calculations and explicitly record a tie if the totals are equal.
- Use an agreed additional criterion or record what information is needed for the next decision.
Example
Fictional example: benefit and ease of execution each have weight 0.5. A scores 4 and 2; B scores 3 and 3. Both totals are 3. Listing A,B does not establish A's superiority. Next, check material availability while retaining the tie.
My Day · Windows
My Day can hold your saved calculation and open question; it does not choose the winner.