My Day✳All blog articles ↗

Independence and mutual exclusion are different properties

No shared outcome does not substitute for checking probabilities.

Mutually exclusive events cannot occur together. Independence is checked by P(A∩B)=P(A)P(B), where the intersection means joint occurrence. These answer different questions; specify the experiment and events first.

9 jointly even pairs among 36 ordered pairs
9 jointly even pairs among 36 ordered pairs

What to do

  1. State the outcomes, their probabilities and which roll each event concerns.
  2. Find joint outcomes and compare their probability with the product of the individual probabilities.
  3. Keep separate conclusions, without calling independence and mutual exclusion universal opposites.

Example

Fictional model: a fair six-sided die numbered 1–6. A=even and B=odd on one roll: joint probability 0, product 1/4; mutually exclusive but dependent. For two independent rolls, C=first even and D=second even: jointly 9 of 36 ordered pairs, 9/36=1/4=(1/2)(1/2). C and D are independent and can occur together.

My Day · Windows

My Day can store definitions and calculations as text. You check the model yourself.

Buy My Day for Windows ↗