Keep first feedback separate before discussion
Capture initial responses separately and preserve them before making a shared summary.
To compare first responses, use the same material and question. Keep the first reader's assessment out of the second reader's initial request. Save originals before discussion and label later clarifications separately. This procedure does not guarantee independent opinions.
What to do
- Agree on help and give each reader the same version and initial question.
- Record what each saw and preserve their named first response.
- Compare the original records, adding later discussion separately rather than replacing their words.
Example
Fictional example: Mia and Noah, 2 readers, separately receive v2 and “Where is the next step unclear?”. Mia writes “The heading is unclear”; Noah writes “The step order is unclear”. Their 2 first responses are saved. Mia's answer was not included in Noah's request; discussion follows saving.
My Day · Windows
In My Day, manually keep both responses with the version and separate space for your decisions.