Record replacement before the next draw
Whether the first item returns determines the population for the second choice.
Specify replacement before calculating a second draw. Returning the first item changes the available population. Keep the already known first outcome attached to the conditional probability.
What to do
- State the starting contents and the random-choice rule, then record which first outcome is already known.
- For each alternative, return or retain the first item and list what is available before draw two.
- Calculate the relevant proportion in that population, explicitly retaining the condition of the known first outcome.
Example
Fictional model: 1 red and 1 blue counter, each present item equally likely. The first drawn counter is known to be red. With replacement, 2 items precede draw two, giving red probability 1/2. Without replacement, 1 blue remains, giving conditional red probability 0. These are model probabilities, not observed frequencies.
My Day · Windows
In My Day, save and reopen the comparison as a text note; check the content yourself.