My Day✳All blog articles ↗

Record replacement before the next draw

Whether the first item returns determines the population for the second choice.

Specify replacement before calculating a second draw. Returning the first item changes the available population. Keep the already known first outcome attached to the conditional probability.

Before draw two: 2 items with replacement, 1 without
Before draw two: 2 items with replacement, 1 without

What to do

  1. State the starting contents and the random-choice rule, then record which first outcome is already known.
  2. For each alternative, return or retain the first item and list what is available before draw two.
  3. Calculate the relevant proportion in that population, explicitly retaining the condition of the known first outcome.

Example

Fictional model: 1 red and 1 blue counter, each present item equally likely. The first drawn counter is known to be red. With replacement, 2 items precede draw two, giving red probability 1/2. Without replacement, 1 blue remains, giving conditional red probability 0. These are model probabilities, not observed frequencies.

My Day · Windows

In My Day, save and reopen the comparison as a text note; check the content yourself.

Buy My Day for Windows ↗