My Day✳All blog articles ↗

Handle conflicting review comments

Clarify the purpose of a revision before choosing the change.

When reviewers suggest opposite changes, trying to do everything can weaken the result. Keep both comments and establish which requirement matters most for this particular material.

2 conflicting comments and 1 agreed criterion
2 conflicting comments and 1 agreed criterion

What to do

  1. Place the conflicting recommendations beside the exact passage so everyone discusses the same object rather than general impressions.
  2. Ask which criterion should determine the choice; if someone else owns the decision, give them a clear description of the conflict.
  3. After clarification, make the chosen change and save the reason; check whether an important requirement from the other comment has been lost.

Example

Fictional example: Dina receives 2 comments: shorten an instruction and add detail. She agrees 1 criterion with reviewers: clarity for a beginner’s first use.

My Day · Windows

In My Day, save a note describing the conflict and a task to agree the criterion; people make the decision.

Buy My Day for Windows ↗