Test a universal claim with a counterexample
Find a permitted case that meets the condition but breaks the conclusion.
A counterexample is an allowed case where a universal claim fails. First check that the example really belongs to the stated group. One such case disproves “all”, but does not make the opposite conclusion true in every case. Isolated supporting examples do not themselves provide a general proof.
What to do
- Write the claim with its word “all” and exact condition.
- Propose a case, then check its condition and claimed conclusion separately.
- Record exactly what was disproved without replacing it with another unsupported generalisation.
Example
Fictional example: test “all rectangles are squares”. A 2×3 cm rectangle has right angles, but its adjacent sides 2 and 3 are unequal. The claim is disproved.
My Day · Windows
My Day can retain the claim, example and study check. You make the logical judgment yourself.